Lord Pengo: Royale Theatre, November 19, 1962

New York Times, November 20, 1962

Theater: 'Lord Pengo'
Charles Boyer in Title Role at the Royale

By HOWARD TAUBMAN

S. N. Behrman’s delight in the charm and skill of a supersalesman of art led him to write a lively and amusing series in The New Yorker some years ago called "The Days of Duveen." Unhappily, he has had no such luck with a fictional art dealer.

"Lord Pengo," which arrived last night at the Royale Theater, is a poor requital to Mr. Behrman for the admiration and affection he evidently has spent on the mystery of selling masterpieces of painting.

Although his play is full of illuminating and no doubt accurate detail about the way in which fantastic deals are put over, it lacks the indispensable ingredients needed in the theater: the development of character and a story with dramatic tension.

Mr. Behrman makes the customary disclaimer about fact and fiction, Lord Pengo is not Lord Duveen. "Though there are great similarities between the two men," Mr. Behrman writes in a program note, "there are also salient differences."

Differences or similarities. What matter which in the face of an inert play? No one can take away from Mr. Behrman, an honored craftsman of the theater, his gift for turning a graceful phrase and writing lines that sparkle with urbane wit. It is manifest In "Lord Pengo," but it cannot carry the piece across the hurdle of an immobile dramatic structure.

*     *     *

Mr. Behrman's very beguilement by Lord Duveen and Lord Pengo has victimized him. He has been at such pains to make his protagonist the irresistible virtuoso of the art galleries that he seems to have concentrated on nothing else. Lord Pengo as Charles Boyer plays him is gay, sophisticated and disarmingly resourceful in his encounters with his millionaire clients. But as you find him at the beginning, so he is at the end. And that is a fatal dramatic flaw.

As the play slips away from him, Mr. Behrman struggles to make you care about what will happen to Lord Pengo. Brian Bedford as the son denounces his father, Lord Pengo, for sacrificing everything to his passion for salesmanship. Bad news of all sorts inundates Lord Pengo's offices. Just when he seems crushed and the second act curtain is to go down, he braces himself, prepares a smile and is ready to resume his manifest destiny as a dealer. But none of this is convincing as a crisis in a man's life.

Nor is the end more convincing. Again the play seeks to stir us with Lord Pengo's gallantry. He is dying and knows it. He says goodbye to his blunt, loyal assistant, Miss Swanson, in a scene meant to be touching. Agnes Moorehead plays with gruff integrity, and Mr. Boyer covers his emotion with a debonair manner. But it is too late. One no longer cares. Lord Pengo, never a human being, remains a performer, and even his farewell is histrionic.

The best scene shows Lord Pengo teasing a dime-store magnate, played with crotchety susceptibility by Cliff Hall, into the purchase of a sculpture of a child's head for $175,000. Henry Daniell as a multimillionaire who builds a national gallery under Pengo's guidance cannot do more than outline a character whom Mr. Behrman merely has sketched. Ruth White as a troubled Mrs. Drury almost makes you believe she is serving some purpose in a dramatic design.

*     *     *

If the externals of atmosphere were decisive, "Lord Pengo" would have few problems. Vincent J. Donehue's staging and Oliver Smith's sets confer credibility on the milieu. And in the final scene there is Rembrandt's "Aristotle Contemplating the Bust of Homr" (a copy, unless the Metropolitan has been careless) on display. You can see the original at the museum for a lot less than the going rates at the Royale.

Lord Pengo: Royale Theatre, November 19, 1962


Copyright © 2009 SNBehrman.com