The Pirate: Martin Beck Theatre, November 25, 1942

New York Times, November 26, 1942

In the Play:

By LEWIS NICHOLS

The theatre celebrated Thanksgiving a little early this year, quietly advancing the clock a few hours in order to bring the Lunts back to town. Anything that serves to return the Lunts to Broadway is an occasion for rejoicing, for they are the theatre's greatest pair of actors, and they have been magnificent in plays from Shakespeare to Sherwood, with snatches of vaudeville thrown in to relieve the danger of too much intensity. This time they are in their vaudeville mood, for "The Pirate," which S. N. Behrman picked up from an idea in a play by Ludwig Fulda, is flamboyant and bizarre, and it gives the Lunts an opportunity for burlesque thus far unparalleled in their combined career.

Mr. Lunt obviously is a vaudeville artist and a hoofer at heart. Quite clearly, when he should have been milking the cows on his renowned Genesee Depot farm, he has been practicing legerdemain, pulling rabbits out of chance visitors' hats and experimenting with the strut that is the hallmark of the more distinguished sleight-of-hand geniuses. In "The Pirate" he has the opportunity to wallow in these new-found joys, and Mr. Lunt is not a vaudeville artist to let his public down. Give him the end of the run and he will move over to Loew's State, there to go on and on as mesmerist and dancer; he has arrived.

*     *     *

That "The Pirate" was written for its distinguished players cannot be doubted, for it is not out of Mr. Behrman's usual drawer—in in fact, some traces of that drawer linger around long enough to throw the play out of joint sometimes, and to slow down the action into good drawing room conversation. At that graceful art Mr. Behrman has no peer, but here he is writing a gaudy tale that should be filled only with high-flown phrases, and the occasional peering forth of the terse epigrammatist serves to distract by changing humor into wit—or just leaving it as conversation.

It is the story of Manuela and Pedro Vargas and Serafin, and, of course, Estramudo, the pirate. Pedro is the stuffy man of business, Manuela the wife who reads the romantic tales of piracy, and Serafin the strolling player who brings his troupe to town to give a performance or so before starving elsewhere. In order to woo Menuela away from her husband, the player boasts that he really is the pirate, a safe gesture on his part, because already he has recognized Estramudo in the person of the man of affairs. It all ends with Serafin carrying his Miss Fontanne off after her quite unwanted husband had been exposed and ordered to jail.

*     *     *

And it is a sufficient plot to set forth before the Lunts, for they can do anything. Miss Fontanne is roguish, coquettish, practical, by turns; she will speak gaily to charming strangers who very likely may be pirates, and she can order them out of her house with a firmness marred only by the slightest of winks. Mr. Lunt can be bumptious or pleading, and, in addition to all that, he can break an egg to make an omelet and then find it turn into a rabbit. The man obviously has studied.

There are many moments of great charm in "The Pirate." The entrance of Mr. Lunt is one. Preceded by a tatterdemalion Negro band, and drawn in a carriage by his fellow-players, he comes across the stage, steps out, does a little dance and then is ready for the business at hand. Another moment is when he walks a tightrope from one balcony to that of his lady, his expression on the journey being a magnificent one of casual concentration. The whole scene of the troupe's performance at the end of the play is the Lunts' type of theatre at its best.

The Playwrights' Company and Theatre Guild, which jointly offered the play, have done a beautiful job of costuming and staging. For direction, there again it is Mr. Lunt and John C. Wilson. The costumes, which are the most gorgeous seen along Broadway in years, are by Miles White, and the settings, in perfect keeping with the play, are Lemuel Ayers's. When the Lunts set out to do a burlesque-vaudeville, they dress it well.

The Pirate: Martin Beck Theatre, November 25, 1942


Copyright © 2009 SNBehrman.com